Danielle Johnson
May 7, 2003

I give permission for my final project to be made available through the LIS Learning Showcase web server.

Part I: Bibliometric Analysis

Introduction: The Journal Applied Geography


Applied Geography
(ISSN: 0143-6228) is a quarterly journal distributed every January, April, July, and October of each year. The journal was born in 1981 (Volume 1) and is currently published in 2004 (Volume 24). The editor is R. Rogerson along with a 15 member editorial board representing six countries. The publisher is Elsevier Science Direct, Ltd., located in Sevenoaks, Kent, England, UK. Prior to 1996, the publisher was Butterworth-Heinemann, Ltd., in Kidlington, Oxford, England, UK.

The format of the journal is available in both print and online. The homepage for the journal provides a current sample edition of Applied Geography. The culture of the journal can be summed up in its slogan, "Putting the World's Human and Physical Resource Problems in a Geographical Perspective." The aim of the journal is to educate those in the fields of geography, geology, environmental studies, globalization, etc. with research methodologies and theories based in geographical dimensions. Individuals and institutions who have an interest in the field range from university students to manufacturers and onward to governmental agencies.

Methodology: Productivity Analysis Reports--Results and Interpretations

Applied Geography is an extensive resource for studying geographic information. In the four sections below Document Types, Citivity, Journal Citation Reports and Author Geographic View will be discussed and interpreted. The five year timespan of the analysis is from 1998-2003. All sections stem from data in ISI--Journal Citation Reports and Web of Science.

A. Document Types
      
Applied Geography invites research articles, commentaries, and reviews. The database ISI Web of Science divides documents according to type. There were four kinds of documents recorded. Articles were the most prevalent because the journal is a forerunner (see impact factor) in producing original research materials.

Document Type/
Frequency by Year
Articles
Book Review
Review
Editorial Notes
Total # of
Documents
1998
28
14
0
2
44
1999
28
6
0
0
34
2000
18
13
1
0
32
2001
14
0
0
0
14
2002
24
0
0
0
24
2003
15
0
0
0
15
Total
127
33
1
2
163

B. Citivity


For Assignment 2, one issue was examined for total number of citations for each document. The results in Applied Geography, Volume 20, Number 3, July 2000: Globalization Population Issues--Edited by Professor Allan Finday are listed below.

Number of Documents in Issue
Number of Citations
1
40
2
35
3
11
4
46
5
71

Citivity from 1998-2002

In all issues of Applied Geography for five years the total citations are counted; numbers are broken down in table format. Data is from ISI/JCR, therefore, numbers may differ slightly from documents counted because, "The article counts given for journals include only original research and review articles." All other documents are excluded, for instance, book reviews and editorials. The statistics are reflected in the impact factor and immediacy index.

Date
Number of Citations
1998
816
1999
688
2000
859
2001
920
2002
842
Total
4125


C. Journal Citation Reports 2002-1998

Directly quoting from ISI's Journal Citation Reports: The journal impact factor is a measure of the frequency with which the "average article" in a journal has been cited in a particular year. The impact factor will help you evaluate a journal's relative importance, especially when you compare it to others in the same field. The journal Immediacy Index is a measure of how quickly the "average article" in a journal is cited. The Immediacy Index will tell you how often articles published in a journal are cited within the same year.

Year
Impact Factor
Immediacy Index
2002
0.316
0.053
2001
0.571
0.105
2000
0.413
0.368
1999
0.660
0.565
1998
0.311
0.304

D.
Authors and Geographic View

Interestingly the most cited authors are from Chiapas, Mexico. Their research focuses on topics about deforestation and other issues in their region. The last three cited authors are from England, the place of publication for Applied Geography.

Top 5 Most Cited Authors from 1998-2003 Times Cited
Institutional Location
Ochoa-Gaona S; Gonzalez-Espinosa M 17
Mexico
Verburg PH; Veldkamp A; Fresco LO 11
Netherlands; Italy
Greenberg M; Krueckeberg D; Lowrie K; Mayer H; Simon D; Isserman A; Sorenson D 10
England
Beaverstock JV; Boardwell JT 9
England
Spellman G 7
England


Conclusion:
Productivity of Applied Geography

The journal has a rich history in developing research and methods within the geography field. Applied Geography caters to even the general reader because article topics cover the human experience. Authors can submit research "on any theme involving the application of geographical theory and methodology in the resolution of human problems." Scholars from across the world submit their findings to the journal to transfer and enhance their knowledge. Although the impact factor of the journal has moved in a roller coaster motion it is evident that scholars continue to utilize the resource.


Part II: Personal Bibliometric Profile of JV Beaverstock
 

Professor Jonathan V. Beaverstock
teaches at Loughborough University in the United Kingdom. His specialty is in Economic Geography with interests in "strategic management, organizational networks and spatialities of financial and professional services in contemporary economic globalization." His unique name allowed for easier searches which pinpointed him out from other scholars. There was one other Beaverstock with initials MC in the field of computer science.

Citation Identity (Authors cited by Beaverstock):

Author's Ouevre: 33 items (14 articles, 18 book reviews, and 1 review) retrieved in WOS/ISI from SSCI Expanded, SSCI, and A&HCI databases within the timespan of 1945-2004. However the results were too tedious to count, therefore timespan was reduced to 1998-2003. Seven articles were then used to count citation identity. Six of the articles are co-authored with five other individuals. Following White's (2000) lead, only articles were used because more than 20 cited references were present. The total number of counted cited references was 408.

Articles
Cited References Count
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Boardwell, JT
Title: Negotiating globalization, transnational corporations and global city financial centres in transient migration studies
Source: APPLIED GEOGRAPHY, 20 (3): 277-304 JUL 2000
71
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ; Walker, DRF; Lorimer, H
Title: Globalization and world cities: some measurement methodologies
Source: APPLIED GEOGRAPHY, 20 (1): 43-63 JAN 2000
69
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Taylor, PJ; Smith, RG
Title: The long arm of the law: London's law firms in a globalising world economy
Source: ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING A, 31 (10): 1857-1876 OCT 1999
63
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ
Title: World city network: A new metageography?
Source: ANNALS OF THE ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN GEOGRAPHERS, 90 (1): 123-134 MAR 2000
59
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV
Title: Transnational elites in global cities: British expatriates in Singapore's financial district
Source: GEOFORUM, 33 (4): 525-538 NOV 2002
55
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Taylor, PJ; Smith, RG
Title: A roster of world cities
Source: CITIES, 16 (6): 445-458 DEC 1999
47
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ
Title: Geographies of globalization: United States law firms in world cities
Source: URBAN GEOGRAPHY, 21 (2): 95-120 FEB-MAR 2000
44
TOTAL CITED REFERENCES COUNT
408

Top five most cited authors by rank are listed below in table. Count was done manually with comparing each cited reference list of each article. (Time consuming task that should have been done with DIALOG. An attempt at DIALOG did not go far because author had no results.) Authors with more than five citations were counted.

Rank
Number of Times Cited
Author
1
14
Beaverstock, JV
2
12
Sassen, S
3
9
Daniels, PW
4
9
Findlay, AM
5 8
Salt, J


Citation Set (authors citing Beaverstock):

Beaverstock had 49 cited lookup selections with a total of 148 individual articles citing him in WOS/ISI. Again timespan parameters were set and list was reduced to 40 cited lookup selections and 99 articles citing Beaverstock. Beaverstock had seven self-citations within the citation set. Other authors noted were Taylor, Findlay and Yeoh.

Citation Image (authors co-cited with Beaverstock):

In Beaverstock's seven articles during 1998-2003 he co-authored six articles. The articles are displayed in descending order of times cited. His co-authors were then researched and it was evident that Taylor and Smith were also citing Beaverstock.

Articles
Times Cited
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Taylor, PJ; Smith, RG
Title: A roster of world cities
Source: CITIES, 16 (6): 445-458 DEC 1999
42
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ
Title: World city network: A new metageography?
Source: ANNALS OF THE ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN GEOGRAPHERS, 90 (1): 123-134 MAR 2000
27
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ
Title: Geographies of globalization: United States law firms in world cities
Source: URBAN GEOGRAPHY, 21 (2): 95-120 FEB-MAR 2000
14
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Boardwell, JT
Title: Negotiating globalization, transnational corporations and global city financial centres in transient migration studies
Source: APPLIED GEOGRAPHY, 20 (3): 277-304 JUL 2000
10
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Taylor, PJ; Smith, RG
Title: The long arm of the law: London's law firms in a globalising world economy
Source: ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING A, 31 (10): 1857-1876 OCT 1999
8
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV; Smith, RG; Taylor, PJ; Walker, DRF; Lorimer, H
Title: Globalization and world cities: some measurement methodologies
Source: APPLIED GEOGRAPHY, 20 (1): 43-63 JAN 2000
6
Author(s): Beaverstock, JV
Title: Transnational elites in global cities: British expatriates in Singapore's financial district
Source: GEOFORUM, 33 (4): 525-538 NOV 2002
3


Part III: Keywords

The precise issue of Applied Geography, Volume 20, Number 3, July 2000 examined in Assignment 2 was unique because it was a based on "Globalization Population Issues." Thus, the keywords, in alphabetical order, surrounds globalization and issues affecting world demographics and populations. Mention of discipline or use and application of a tool is not mentioned. Yet, Geographic Information Science as an umbrella discipline would cover the terms. An obvious act of interdisciplinarity is evident. Economic Geography is such, created from the disciplines of economics and geography.

Subject Keywords, Descriptors, Classification Codes
AIDS
banking
behavior
biographical approach
cities
demographic deficit
demography
elderly population
fertility decline
global environmental processes
globalcity
globalization
globalization
HIV
Hong Kong
labor migration
land
markets
migration
mortality rates
networks
New York City
out-migration
plec
political ecology
population geography
skilled international migration
Spain
Thailand
transient migration
underpopulation
work

Part IV: Essay

“General readers still generally regard footnoted, endnoted or parenthetical citations as a dispensable nuisance” (Merton, 2000). As a general reader one tends to overlook citations. However bibliometrics is the actual study of citations. Bibliometrics applies quantitative methods and results to statistical findings about books and journals. The word "bibliometrics" is the "fusion" of two words meaning the measurement of bibliographies (Sengupta, 1992). The usefulness of the methods have been studied and theorized. Theories in bibliometrics started with Lotka’s, Bradford's, and Zipf’s Laws in the 1930s (http://www.gslis.utexas.edu/~palmquis/courses/biblio.html). Applying the three laws determines "frequency" of articles to journals, author publications, and words in texts. The statistics generated are useful in showing the growth of a journal, author profiles, citation analyses and keywords; "no other method provides as comprehensive coverage of a topic in scientific communication" (von Ungern-Sternberg, 2000). Analyses are important because they chart growth and trends in various disciplines.

Of even greater interest is the merging of disciplines. "Now references and citations could move information across time and across disciplinary boundaries, unhindered by the ambiguity of terminology, geography, or ideology" (Small, 2000). Bibliometrics helps to understand the "cross-fertilization" of disciplines (Cole, 2000). Coleman's (2002) overview of interdisciplinarity traces the attempts to merge the disciplines of Library and Information Science (LIS) and Computer Science (CS). Her findings concluded, "Professional schools such as LIS need to focus even more on interdisciplinarity because of the wealth of competencies such as improved technology and social interaction skills that interdisciplinarity provides." Library schools need to prepare future librarians about the issues they will encounter in their respective fields. Issues about maintaining statistics and their effects on the library.

Ten years before Sengupta attempted to discuss the history and goal of "librametrics": the basic aim of librametric studies is to help generation of new knowledge by organising a need-based library system and its utility rests on the fact that it can provide some potential tools which may help to ensure quantitative measurement of cost-effectiveness and cost-benefit of investment in the library sector (1992). Librametrics as a particular field of library sciences was not established. Although, interdisciplinarity and its aims are similar.

Interdisciplinarity is not a new interest or idea. Crucial concerns are still the same today in regards to the increase of expenditures. The cost of running a library lies in keeping statistics. "Expenditures for serials by research libraries increased 210% between 1986-2001 while the CPI increased 62%. The typical library spent 3 times as much but purchased 5% fewer titles" (http://www.arl.org/scomm/open_access/framing.html). Libraries are experiencing spending reductions. The University of Arizona Libraries issued a statement pertaining to serials cuts.

As a result of two years of flat budgets and increasing prices for journals, databases and books, the Library must reduce spending on information resources by approximately $1.4 million over the next two years. Some of the reduction will be accomplished by buying fewer books, but some journals must also be cancelled in order to stay within our budget (http://www.library.arizona.edu/library/teams/sst/ua_libraryexpenditures.htm).

Inflation of serials and publisher monopolies are made visible through bibliometrics. Managing statistics by studying the growth and trends in LIS is vital in sustaining the discipline. Although phenomenal costs and rates of journals are occurring there are other options. An option in scholarly communication is the creation of digital libraries and their repositories. The digital arena is available for scholars to submit their research and work. Again, the field is new and challenges are many. Just as Garfield experienced obstacles in indexing, digital libraries and repositories are facing the same hindrance. Digital libraries and repositories must find ways to track data.

Indexing digital libraries and repositories is a huge task. One option is to have researchers keep autonomous citation indexes (ACI). "An ACI system can find articles by searching the Web, monitoring mailing lists or newsgroups, or by linking directly to publishers. Once familiar with ACI systems, researchers will be able to notify the systems of new papers directly, allowing these papers to be indexed almost immediately" (Lawrence, Giles, & Bollacker, 1999). The innovation is based on a self-motivation idea for serious scholars. Scholars who want to pursue and sustain electronic publishing are the target audience. Although it would be ideal for all scholars to keep an ACI. ACI is needed because there is an overload of information on the Internet. Webmetrics is the study of such information and data being stored on web sites and web pages. "Sitations" a term coined by Cronin pertains to counting citations on web sites (2000).

The count factor is a major determent for webmetrics because the study is based on keeping track of such numbers. Counting Online Usage of Networked Electronic Resources (COUNTER) was established to find a way to keep count of online resources, namely databases and journals. "The use of online information resources has been growing exponentially and it is widely agreed by producers and purchasers of information that the use of these resources should be measured in a more consistent way" (http://www.projectcounter.org/about.html). COUNTER intends to offer librarians a way to "compare usage statistics from different vendors; make better-informed purchasing decisions; plan infrastructure more effectively."  Reports and codes of practice are initiated, reviewed and provided on the website. Many challenges are obvious in maintaining webmetrics. "Work in progress" or "site under construction" are phrases reflecting the future of webmetrics and the potential that it encompasses.

Returning to the "general reader" who may have no interest in bibliometrics or webmetrics, one can see that they participate in the cycle. General readers are information users. Even though they may not see the importance of evaluating journal articles through citation analyses their mere use of journals is evident within the scholarly communication cycle. Especially with the Internet. The Internet is widely available to most individuals who may be overwhelmed at the wealth of information by the "click of the mouse."

References

    Cole, J.R. (2000). A short history of the use of citations as a measure of the impact of scientific and scholarly work. In The web of knowledge: A festschrift in honor of Eugene Garfield. Medford, NJ: Information Today, Inc.

    Coleman, A. (2002). Interdisciplinarity: The road ahead for education in digital libraries. [Electronic source] D-Lib Magazine (8), 7-8. <http://www.dlib.org/dlib/july02/coleman/07coleman.html>

    COUNTER--Online Usage of Electronic Sources. <http://www.projectcounter.org/about.html>

    Davenport, E., and Cronin B. (2000). The citation network as a prototype for representing trust in virtual environments. In The web of knowledge: A festschrift in honor of Eugene Garfield. Medford, NJ: Information Today, Inc.

        Lawrence, S., Giles C. Lee, & Bollacker, K. (1999) Digital Libraries and Autonomous Citation Indexing. IEEE Computer, (32), 6, 67-71.

    Library Serials Project. <http://www.library.arizona.edu/library/teams/sst/ua_libraryexpenditures.htm>

    Merton, R.K. (2000). On the Garfield input to the sociology of science: A retrospective collage. In The web of knowledge: A festschrift in honor of Eugene Garfield. Medford, NJ: Information Today, Inc.

    Sengupta, I.N. (1992). Bibliometrics, infometrics, scientometrics and librametrics: An overview. Libri (42), 2, 75-98.

    Small, H. (2000). Charting pathways through science: Exploring Garfield’s vision of a unified index to science. In The web of knowledge: A festschrift in honor of Eugene Garfield. Medford, NJ: Information Today, Inc.

    Von Ungern-Sternberg, S. (2000). Scientific communication and bibliometrics. <http://www/abo.fi/~sungern/comm00.htm>